Orange is the New Black’s Season 2 debut finds Piper Chapman facing consequences. Ryan wonders whether it’s enough.
At first glance, Orange is the New Black began its sophomore season in the worst possible way. Instead of the break I’d hoped her visit to the SHU would provide, we got a full hour of The
Truman Chapman Show, wondering what’s next for her.1 It’s 20 minutes before we know where Chapman is going, and another 20 until we find out why, from none other than Alex Vause. In the meantime, we get to endure Chapman’s various unpleasant experience, not knowing whether this facility and its cast of characters will become the new normal.
In a continuation from last season, Jenji Kohan et al are trying very hard to gain empathy for Chapman. OITNB has never been particularly subtle, but this time it’s just blatantly trying to manipulate the audience. We’re supposed to have pity as the women in her family teach her to bottle up her feelings2, listen sympathetically as she pours her heart out to us (and Tank Girl), cringe as Chapman’s bunkmate assaults her to find out exact time of her birth. Don’t you want to give her a hug and tell her it’ll all be okay?3
At second glance, “Thirsty Bird” plants some interesting seeds for the rest of the season. Alex, Larry, Crazy Eyes, Miss Claudette — all of the people who cared for Chapman are either gone or not speaking to her. The U.S. Marshal who lets her use the bathroom on the plane only does so to prevent her from peeing her pants, which would mean either more work or more smell for him. Alex appears to be protecting Chapman, but (predictably) goes for the double-cross to get herself out of the clink. Larry’s father represents Chapman for the trial but then taps out, not because he’s emotionally invested and disappointed, but because he can’t abide her perjury.
Even as we’re shown situations where we (are supposed to) feel bad for her, Chapman is reaping the bad karma she sowed last season, and finding it’s isolation. This could be a very positive new trajectory for Season 2. Is it enough to keep Orange is the New Black from going off the rails, a la Weeds? More importantly, is it enough to keep me from turning into a hate-watcher? It just might be, provided the action quickly returns to Litchfield.
Tomorrow: Mooch reviews episode 2, “Looks Blue, Tastes Red.”
- Or, in my case, wondering what I did to deserve having this episode to review. ↵
- Related: is it a surprise to anybody that Chapman has been a goody-two-shoes her entire life? ↵
- In case you were wondering, the correct answer is NOPE. Assault is never okay, but let’s be honest, I’d not rush to comfort her. ↵